The Insurance Name You Can Trust

About Crotty Insurance

An Insurance Partner You Can Trust!

Crotty Insurance Agency, Inc. has been providing exceptional, affordable insurance to residents and businesses in Pennsylvania, New York, and Ohio for over 29 years. We are an independent insurance agency representing many of the top insurers in the county including Travelers, Ohio Casualty, Penn National, Encompass and Progressive just to name a few. Our professionals will tailor make a program to fit your specific needs, whether for your personal insurance or for your business. We are a family-run business with a caring, personal touch. At Crotty Insurance, you’re not just a customer, you’re family. Let us be your one stop shop for all your insurance needs!

Meet the Crotty Insurance Team


Dennis M Crotty - Crotty Insurance Agent Erie
Dennis M. Crotty
President
Ken Crotty - Crotty Insurance Agent Erie
Ken Crotty
Vice President

Lee Eighmy - Crotty Insurance Agent
Lee Eighmy
Agent
Al Dore - Erie Insurance Agent
Al Dore
Agent
Jackie McDonald - Crotty Insurance Agent Erie PA
Jackie McDonald
Agent
Matt Crotty - Crotty Insurance Agent
Matt Crotty
Agent

Karen Keinath - Customer Service at Crotty Insurance
Karen Keinath
Customer Service
Mary Kay Yonko - Accounting at Crotty Insurance
Mary Kay Yonko
Accounting


Western Pennsylvania Insurance Agencies - Independent Insurance Agent

Why Choose Crotty Insurance?

As an independent insurance agency, we represent your interests, not the interests of any one insurance company. As a result, we’re able to offer you customization, choice and a level of consultation not found with a direct writer or online insurance provider. Whether you need personal insurance, business insurance, or car insurance, we’ll research your options and craft a personalized, competitively-priced insurance protection program just for you.

And should you ever suffer a loss, we’ll be here for you every step of the way to make sure your claim is settled quickly and fairly. After all, insurance is really just a promise to get you back on your feet should something unexpected happen. You can rely on Crotty Insurance to deliver on that promise.

Crotty Insurance is owned and operated by seasoned insurance brokers and staff with over 60 years of combined insurance experience.

  • Our staff is here to solve your problems quickly.
  • Our objective is to provide you with an excellent customer service experience.
  • We can give you a free quote upon request for any type of insurance.
  • We can deal with all your insurance needs, even if you have a bad driving record or prior health issues.
  • We will provide you with quotes from A rated companies at the most competitive pricing around.

THE NAME YOU CAN TRUST!

100% MONEY BACK GUARANTEE